Employee disengagement is a critical challenge facing credit unions in 2025, and you're likely feeling its impact on your organization. With employee recruitment and retention being a top concern for nearly half (46%) of credit unions, the financial services industry is grappling with staffing shortages that directly affect member service quality and operational efficiency.

The credit union sector faces unique challenges that traditional engagement methods haven't adequately addressed. Credit unions across the country face increasing pressure from evolving technological shifts, heightened security threats, competitive disruptions, regulatory complexities, and workforce challenges.

In this article, you will learn how credit unions can identify engagement issues early, take meaningful action, and create a culture where employees feel heard and valued, ultimately leading to better member experiences and stronger organizational performance.

Why disengaged employees are a growing challenge for modern credit unions

Credit union employee engagement challenges have reached concerning levels. While Gallup workforce engagement statistics show troubling trends with only 31% of U.S. employees actively engaged at work and 17% actively disengaged, credit unions face additional sector-specific pressures that compound these issues.

According to Wipfli's 2025 State of Credit Unions Report, banking leaders identify employee-related challenges as significant obstacles to member engagement, with employee recruitment and retention ranking as a top concern for credit unions. For credit unions specifically, this translates to direct impacts on member satisfaction and loyalty, as engaged employees are fundamental to delivering the personalized, community-focused service that differentiates credit unions from larger banks.

employee-engagement-trend-graph

Gallup. (2025). Employee engagement sinks to a year-low. Gallup. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/654911/employee-engagement-sinks-year-low.aspx

Credit unions are navigating a complex landscape in 2025. According to Wipfli's State of Credit Unions Report, 96% expect business growth, yet they simultaneously face cybersecurity threats and increasing regulatory pressures. These mounting operational challenges are contributing to rising employee disconnection across the industry. To stay competitive in serving members, credit unions must understand what's driving disengagement and take proactive steps to address it.

Here are some of the biggest factors contributing to the rise of disengagement in credit unions:

  • Burnout: High workloads, overwhelming demands, and blurred boundaries, especially as credit unions implement new technologies and security protocols, can leave employees mentally and emotionally exhausted. With 57% of credit unions increasing cybersecurity technology investments, staff face mounting pressure without regular chances to voice concerns.
  • Lack of feedback and action: When credit union employees are unable to provide feedback about member service challenges, technology implementations, or process improvements, they start to feel disconnected from the organization's mission. This lack of communication erodes trust and leads to frustration, which causes disengagement. Many credit unions gather feedback without taking meaningful action, leaving employees feeling unheard.
  • Limited growth opportunities: As the credit union industry evolves rapidly, with 75% now using AI-based tools and 62% participating in banking-as-a-service, employees need clear paths for skill development and career advancement. Without these opportunities, staff start to feel stuck in their roles and become disengaged.
  • Weak organizational culture: When your credit union's culture doesn't align with its cooperative values or member-first mission, employee engagement suffers. With increasing pressure from fintech competition and regulatory changes, maintaining strong feedback loops, recognition, and a sense of belonging becomes even more critical.
  • Changing workplace dynamics:  The shift to digital-first member services and hybrid work has reshaped how credit union employees engage with their organizations. Without intentional efforts to build connection while implementing new technologies, engagement will continue to decline.

The impact of employee disengagement

As disengagement increases in credit unions, it can have a negative impact on both employees and member service quality. If left unaddressed, the effects become harder to reverse, making it critical for credit union leaders to understand the full scope of disengagement's impact on organizational stability and long-term success.

  • Member-service impact: Disengaged credit union employees are less likely to provide the personalized, community-focused service that members expect. This directly affects member satisfaction and loyalty which are critical differentiators for credit unions competing against larger banks and fintech companies.
  • Challenges with productivity and innovation: With credit unions prioritizing digital transformation (improving digital engagement is the top strategic priority for 58% of institutions), disengaged employees put in less effort toward technology adoption and process improvement initiatives.
  • Business performance: As disengagement spreads, employee turnover increases. For credit unions already struggling with talent shortages, particularly in IT and cybersecurity roles that 31% plan to hire, this leads to higher recruitment costs, loss of talent, and disruption of team dynamics.
  • Cultural deterioration: When credit union employees disconnect from the cooperative mission and member-first values, it weakens the organizational culture that has traditionally set credit unions apart from commercial banks.

The role of employee surveys in credit union employee engagement

Employee surveys and continuous feedback loops are critical tools for credit unions to sustain employee engagement and address disengagement early. These tools help credit union leaders:

  • Understand employees' concerns about member service and operational challenges in real-time
  • Identify issues before they impact member satisfaction
  • Create transparent, trusting work environments that align with cooperative values
  • Act on feedback to improve both employee experience and member service

Traditional methods used by credit unions are often reactive rather than proactive, missing the opportunity to engage employees before problems arise.  According to recent research in partnership with HR.com, the most common methods used to measure engagement are:

  • 64% use exit interviews
  • 58% rely on annual surveys
  • 53% focus on retention rates

These methods typically occur after an employee has disengaged or left the company. This is why continuous feedback is a game-changer for credit unions. Unlike annual surveys, they enable leaders to keep a pulse on engagement over time and respond to concerns as they arise. This allows you to make adjustments before issues escalate and helps drive continuous improvement in engagement.

Anonymity drives honest feedback

Anonymity also plays a crucial role in gathering honest, actionable feedback within credit union environments. Given the close-knit nature of many credit union teams and communities, employees may hesitate to speak up about operational challenges or leadership concerns without anonymity protection.

When credit union employees are assured their responses are anonymous, they are more likely to share honest feedback about member service challenges, technology implementation issues, and organizational culture concerns. This results in more valuable insights for improving both employee experience and member satisfaction.

You can’t drive change without taking action on feedback

Surveys and feedback only work if credit unions are willing to take action on the insights they gather. Our data reveals that only about half of organizations take significant actions to improve engagement based on feedback, and two-fifths fail to communicate survey results across the organization. Meanwhile, we found that 77% of highly engaged organizations prioritize taking specific actions based on employee feedback.

For credit unions, taking action on feedback is particularly important because it demonstrates the cooperative values of member-owner participation and democratic decision-making. When credit union leaders act quickly on employee insights, it reinforces the collaborative culture that attracts both employees and members to the credit union movement.

How modern credit unions use technology to motivate disengaged employees

Employee surveys and structured feedback mechanisms are essential for credit unions to understand and address disengagement effectively. This is particularly relevant as credit unions accelerate technology adoption, with 75% currently using AI-based tools and 90% planning AI implementation within 12 months.

Our research proves that organizations embracing employee survey technology see substantial improvements in key performance areas. 93% of organizations that invested in employee survey software reported a positive or neutral ROI, with 65% seeing higher employee productivity and performance. These are critical metrics for credit unions focused on member service excellence.

Real-time analytics

Leveraging technology to track engagement allows credit union leaders to measure employee sentiment continuously. Unlike traditional methods like annual surveys, real-time analytics enable leaders to quickly spot early signs of disengagement that could impact member service quality. This is where technology truly shines for credit unions. By providing instant access to valuable data, leaders can take swift action to resolve issues before they affect member satisfaction or operational performance.

Measure progress over time

As credit unions undergo digital transformation initiatives, the right survey software allows leaders to track and measure engagement progress over time. With improving digital engagement being the top strategic priority for 58% of credit unions, continuously aligning employee feedback with technology implementation goals becomes essential. This cycle ensures that feedback doesn't just sit in a report. It actively drives engagement and keeps employees aligned with the credit union's mission during periods of rapid change.

Actionable insights

When selecting a survey tool, credit union leaders should look for platforms that do more than just collect data. The tool should offer actionable recommendations specific to financial services and include capabilities to help track progress during technology implementations, regulatory changes, and member service improvements.

Learn from highly-engaged organizations

Our research finds that almost half of highly engaged organizations say a whopping 80% of their workforce is highly engaged.

Here's what highly engaged organizations do differently. These are insights that credit unions can apply:

  • They measure employee engagement: 58% of highly engaged organizations measure employee engagement, compared to just 44% of less engaged organizations.
  • They collect data more frequently: 56% of highly engaged organizations collect engagement data at least twice a year or quarterly, while only 39% of less engaged organizations do the same.
  • They share data: 41% of highly engaged organizations share data in real-time with leaders, compared to only 28% of less engaged organizations.
  • They take action based on their data: 77% of highly engaged organizations take specific action based on engagement data, versus just 33% of less engaged organizations.
  • Leaders take responsibility: 84% of highly engaged organizations are more likely to place responsibility for improving employee engagement on immediate supervisors, compared to only 53% of less engaged organizations.

Proof that employee engagement drives success for credit unions

The connection between employee engagement and member satisfaction is particularly strong in credit unions, where personal relationships and community connection drive loyalty. Research shows that engaged credit union employees directly impact member experience, retention, and overall satisfaction.

Here are real examples of credit unions that have transformed their employee engagement and seen direct business results:

  • Arrowhead Credit Union reduced turnover by 49% and saved 40% on its rewards budget by moving to WorkTango's centralized recognition program. This dramatic reduction in turnover meant preserving valuable member relationships and institutional knowledge while significantly cutting recruitment and training costs.
  • Apple Federal Credit Union achieved 91% supervisor and 85% employee engagement within three months of launch, with 52% cross-department recognition participation. This high level of engagement created a collaborative culture that enhanced member service across all touchpoints.
  • RBFCU tied recognition to member service KPIs and saw a 17% decrease in turnover and 68% increase in employees hitting higher member service scores. By directly connecting employee engagement to member experience metrics, RBFCU demonstrated the clear link between staff satisfaction and member satisfaction.

These results show that when credit unions invest in employee engagement through structured feedback and recognition programs, they see measurable improvements in both employee retention and member service quality.

Learn more about how employee engagement drives member experience in credit unions to understand the specific strategies these credit unions used to achieve these results.

A graphic with text reads "How Credit unions are driving culture change"